Cardus:Making spanking illegal does more harm than good

Making spanking illegal does more harm than good, says Cardus

Trending: Register News and Notes Malta Knights Oldest bishops priest honoured

“Spanking bans are not an example of evidence-based policy-making,” said Program Director for Cardus Family, Andrea Mrozek.
“Spanking bans are not an example of evidence-based policy-making,” said Program Director for Cardus Family, Andrea Mrozek. Photo courtesy of Pro Woman Pro Life [http://bit.ly/2kycopR]
Making spanking illegal does more harm than good, says Cardus
By Deborah Gyapong, Canadian Catholic News

January 26, 2017

OTTAWA – As an anti-spanking bill winds through Canada’s Senate, a Christian think tank is sounding an alarm that it will do “more harm than good” and still fail to prevent child abuse.
Top Stories

‘Life is winning in America,’ vice president tells March for Life rally
Pope Francis offers prayers, sends greetings to March for Life
Catholics south of U.S. border say Trump’s wall won’t deter desperate migrants
Pro-life march, Pope doctor dies, slain priest honoured: Register News and Notes
Fr. Damian MacPherson leaving Archdiocese Interfaith post

Bill S-206, introduced in December 2015 by Senator Céline Hervieux-Payette, would remove the Criminal Code section 43, allowing parents and teachers to use « reasonable force » when disciplining children in their care.

“The main problem of repealing section 43 is the use of state coercion to tell parents how to parent,” says Cardus Family in a Jan. 26 publication.

Senator Hervieux-Payette retired in 2016, leaving former Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) Chair Senator Murray Sinclair to shepherd the bill, now at second reading, through the Senate.

The physical abuse many Indigenous children suffered in the Indian Residential Schools prompted the TRC to call for the repeal of section 43 in one of its 94 Calls to Action that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has promised to implement.

The so-called « spanking law » was last reviewed in 2004 and upheld by the Supreme Court.

In “Parental Discipline: The Case for Keeping Section 43,” Cardus Family said the abuse experienced by First Nations children “would be clearly illegal even with section 43.” The abuse started with forcibly removing the children from their homes, Cardus Family argues. “This abuse stemmed from interference with parents, just as repealing section 43 likewise interferes in the lives of parents.”

In a review of countries where bans on force are in place, Cardus Family found “children have been removed from their homes unnecessarily.”

“The removal of section 43 will put good parents at risk of criminal sanction and will not help protect children from abuse,” the study says.

“Spanking bans are not an example of evidence-based policy-making,” said Andrea Mrozek, Program Director for Cardus Family. “Repealing Section 43 would give the government another opportunity to intrude into the homes and lives of loving parents seeking to discipline their children reasonably.”

The report shows many of the studies linking spanking to harm fail to distinguish between “spanking used appropriately and abuse.”

Since Sweden banned reasonable force in 1979, criminal assaults by and against minors have “sky-rocketed in Swedish criminal statistics,” and children under seven have experienced an increase in child abuse 21 times higher than previously, the study says. In Sweden, minor-against-minor violence is up 23 times higher than just after the ban.

Cardus Family points out fewer parents in Canada are opting for spanking when disciplining their children.

The think tank is not advocating spanking as the only tool in a parent’s disciplinary tool box. “Those in favour of the limited use of reasonable force do indeed mean limited and are against not only abuse but also the overly frequent use of reasonable force,” the study says.

“Parents struggling to cope with defiant young children, at danger of hurting themselves, who use one or two swats on the bottom should know there is no compelling research to suggest this is harmful,” the study says. “Parents need to be able to decide how they are going to discipline their children, and this may not include the use of reasonable force, but it may.”
Tagged under:

Cardus Senator Céline HervieuxPayette Bill S206 Criminal Code section 43 spanking

Related items

Cardus makes sure faith is part of Canada’s 150th celebrations
Cardus selects cabinet to mark Canada’s 150th
More protection needed for religious freedom, says Rabbi Sacks
Questions raised about Liberal promise to ban spanking
No reason to celebrate as same-sex marriage turns 10

« Murders of Mexican clergy won’t stop missionary work, says Canadian priest
Gender theory is moving too fast, say Campaign Life officials »
Leave your comments
Login to post a comment

Username Password

Remember me
Register Forgot password
Post comment as a guest

Name (Required):
Email:
Website:

0 / 300
Your comments are subject to administrator’s moderation.
Subscribe

Comments | Add yours

Sort by Oldest First
Sort by Latest First
Email
RSS

No comments found


Opinion
JohnMilloy
Debate over assisted dying isn’t over yet

John Milloy says the Canadian society needs to determine where the euthanasia line should be drawn.
Faith

Prayer requires a sharp focus (Part 2 of 4)
Prayer requires a sharp focus (Part 2 of 4)
This is the second in a series of four columns by Fr.…

Pope’s homily
CatholicEdBanner
God frees us from fear of everything, the sin that paralyzes Christians

Read the latest homily given by Pope Francis.
Features

Archdiocese of Toronto among growing number making move to ethical investing
Archdiocese of Toronto among growing number making move to ethical investing
Don’t invest in what you don’t believe in is more than sage,…

FrontButton
Catholic Register – Crosswords Vol II big box
THE DIGITAL EDITION
NewDigitalEditionButtonFlat
LoginHere

Catholic Missions
NEWSLETTER

Newsletter

THIS ISSUE

Print Edition: January 29, 2017

Cover012917

SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

Latest News
Most Read
Latest Opinion

‘Life is winning in America,’ vice president tells March for Life rally
‘Life is winning in America,’ vice president tells March for Life rally
January 27, 2017
Pope Francis offers prayers, sends greetings to March for Life
Pope Francis offers prayers, sends greetings to March for Life
January 27, 2017
Catholics south of U.S. border say Trump’s wall won’t deter desperate migrants
Catholics south of U.S. border say Trump’s wall won’t deter desperate migrants
January 27, 2017
Pro-life march, Pope doctor dies, slain priest honoured: Register News and Notes
Pro-life march, Pope doctor dies, slain priest honoured: Register News and Notes
January 27, 2017
Fr. Damian MacPherson leaving Archdiocese Interfaith post
Fr. Damian MacPherson leaving Archdiocese Interfaith post
January 27, 2017

Catholic Register logo

Products

The Catholic Register
The Digital Edition
Catholic Register Books

Publicités

Laisser un commentaire

Entrez vos coordonnées ci-dessous ou cliquez sur une icône pour vous connecter:

Logo WordPress.com

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte WordPress.com. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Google+

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Google+. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Image Twitter

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Twitter. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Facebook

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Facebook. Déconnexion /  Changer )

w

Connexion à %s